A weblog that provides match reports and discussion about high school girls and youth rugby in Wisconsin.
Wednesday, December 19, 2007
Use those sideline ropes
Multiple youth teams were playing games on a football field with the youth fields laid out running from side-line to side-line of the full-sized field. As a result, the middle fields shared a sideline. The coach was injured when a player from the adjacent field ran out of bounds and struck the coach, injuring his knee. The coach sued, alleging that the the organizers were negligent in not laying out the fields to allow a safety zone between fields.
The court tossed about whether the coach was a spectator, and therefore subject to the "Baseball Rule" or a participant, and therefore subject to Wis. Stat. s. 895.525(4m) which allows for recovery for injuries in a contact sport "only if the participant who caused the injury acted recklessly or with intent to cause injury." cf. my prior post. The "Baseball Rule", in brief, is that a spectator assumes the risk of attending a sporting event and, therefore cannot sue if, for instance, they are hit by a foul ball or some other foreseeable consequence of attending a particular type of sporting event. Ultimately, the court concluded that the coach was a hybrid spectator/participant and that his own negligence precluded recovery. In other words, when standing on a sideline between two fields, the coach should have known that he might get run into by a player from the other field.
Youth rugby guidelines recommend laying out youth fields in a similar manner (i.e. two fields running width wide across a rugby pitch) -- but suggest having a 5-10m safety zone between the sideline and the field goal posts and a 10m safety zone between the youth pitches -- if only they had been playing rugby this all could have been avoided. More importantly, the court's holding in Shain is directly applicable to the involvement of coaches in rugby in the event a coach (or spectator) is injured on the sideline -- when attending a rugby game -- people standing on the sideline should know that players may run about of bounds and you may get hurt. Therefore, it is best for spectators to stand behind the sideline ropes and for people in front of the sideline ropes to pay attention to the game, so that injury can be avoided.
Friday, December 14, 2007
Vis unita fortior
Monday, December 10, 2007
Help Wanted In Kenosha
Wednesday, November 28, 2007
Id nos vinixisemus'
I can't verify the authenticity of the Latin -- I'm pretty sure that should be vinxissemus --- (the pluperfect subjective) --- but perhaps I have it wrong. In any event, its a fun one.
Wednesday, November 21, 2007
The Laws are the law...
In 1988, Old Blue RFC and Mystic River RFC were playing a game at the Can-AM Rugby Tournament. During the game, a Mystic player was lying on the ball during a ruck. The sir called the penalty and blew the whistle to stop play. After the whistle, an Old Blue player the defendant "ran towards" the player on the ground and kicked him in the face. The sir penalized Old Blue and sent the player off immediately.
The injured player later sued the player who kicked him, Old Blue Rugby Club, its Captain and officers (on the theory that they were negligent in recruitment and discipline of the player (who was a professional playing in an amateur game), the tournament organizers (because they were negligent in inviting Old Blue to play in the tournament and should have been aware of Old Blue's reputation for violence).
The defendants moved to dismiss the lawsuit based on the "assumption of risk" doctrine --i.e. that the player, by entering the rugby game, understood the risks and by playing the game "consented to those injury-causing events which are known, apparent or reasonably foreseeable consequences of the participation." This doctrine is generally true, but where the conduct which causes injury was "reckless or intentional" the person can be held liable and potentially those individuals (like the team captain/officers/coaches) who knew or should have known about the player's propensity to play outside the rules.
In denying the motion to dismiss, the court noted that the injury occurred after the whistle had stopped play for the first penalty. The question of whether the injury was "foreseeable" (and therefore within the "assumption of risk" doctrine) depends on factors, including but not limited to "the ultimate purpose of the game and the method or methods of winning it; the relationship between the defendant's conduct to the game's ultimate purpose, especially his conduct with respect to rules and customs whose purpose is to enhance safety of the participants; and the equipment involved in playing the game."
In analyzing these factors, court noted that the type of play involved in the case (i.e. kicking a player after the whistle had blown) had no relationship to the rules of the game of rugby:
Although rugby is an inherently rough contact sport, the act of kicking someone after play has been stopped has no relation to a team's ultimate purpose of gaining possession of or advancing the ball.
Furthermore, such an act is a flagrant violation of the rules of rugby, which state "it is illegal for any player willfully to hack or kick an opponent or to trip him with the foot, or to trample on the opponent lying on the ground."
Therefore, because the player's conduct was flagrantly outside of the laws of Rugby, the judge allowed the claim to proceed to trial. Moreover, the court found that there were material issues of fact as to whether Old Blue, its officer and captain and the tournament organizers should have known that this player had a tendency to flagrantly violate the Laws of rugby when playing.
The lesson for coaches and players should be obvious. We can't tolerate dangerous play and coaches must be sure to discipline players appropriately (i.e. suspending players who have been issued red cards by the sir) and instructing players regarding proper play.
Let me just say one more time -- this isn't a rugby issue. The Court's ruling was actually based on an suit involving jockeys and horse racing, Turcotte v. Fell, 68 N.Y.2d 432 (1986).
Monday, November 19, 2007
The All Star Matches
The U-17 Eagles, which also had a Wisconsin contingent took 5th place with a 24-0 victory over Mid-Atlantic u-19 select side.
Sanctissimum Iisden Studiis Initiari Vinculum Amicitiae
Around the high school girls rugby community at least two clubs have a Latin mottoes:
- Fortis et Audax (Strong and Bold) is the motto which appeared on the crest (the yellow and red roses) of the DSHA RFC in the early years. The crest has lost the Latin motto, but it retains the roses.
- Caritas in Omnibus (Charity in all things) is the school motto for CMH.
Along with the practical law for rugby players, we'll throw in some Latin mottoes until the season starts up in the Spring.
Friday, November 16, 2007
The trials and tribulations of coaching...
If a parent is willing to sue a baseball coach for not teaching a kid to slide, just think what a parent would do if a coach didn't teach a player to properly tackle, scrum, ruck, etc... Coaches should really spend the time getting USARFU certifications and reading up on teaching safety to their players. Clubs should invest in their coaches and help defray the cost of training program for these volunteers (with one or two notable exceptions). Investing in coach training makes the sport safer and more enjoyable for all. Having said that, I think our Wisconsin teams have an excellent record of both coaches and sirs stressing safety first when training new players. Let's keep up the good work and not end up like that ruffian sport, baseball.
Since its the off-season, I will try to report on some of those pesky legal topics that surround the rugby community. Hopefully, this will be of interest to some readers.
Wednesday, November 14, 2007
U-20 Eagles
Congratulations girls and good luck this weekend.
Friday, November 9, 2007
Girls Health In Wisconsin
Another mystery that emerged from the report relates to girls' health. They watch less television than their male counterparts, but report falling below recommended levels of physical activity.Our community, i.e. rugby in Wisconsin, offers high school girls something unique. It is an opportunity for a girl to become fully involved in a sport, even if she has not been participating and playing it since she was 3 years old. This provides an opportunity for everyone from star athletes who are burnt out on another sport to girls who just never found thier niche. The Wisconsin rugby community should be proud of its efforts and should recognize that what we do is more than just a shot at a winning a sports competition, but an opportunity to help young women thrive.
"They're not exactly couch potatoes, but what is it? Are they texting on their phones?" O'Brien said. "We want interpretation from girls who are living it."
The full report is available on the Wisconsin Women's Council website.
News from the Colonies (i.e. us)
The FRU prominently features profiles of the UWM Panther players in anticipation of their Midwest Final 4 match this weekend, Nov. 10th. Good luck to the Panthers as they take on Bowling Green in their upcoming semi-final match.
Wednesday, November 7, 2007
Our First Alumna Eagle!
While alumnae of Wisconsin high school teams have featured prominently on the US U-19 team and even on the U-23 team, Kati's selection for the tour represents the first time an alumna of a Wisconsin high school team has been selected as a senior side Eagle. Kati played with the Kettle Moraine Knightmares for 4 years while in high school and was part of the 2004 team which placed 2nd at the NIT. Here is a picture of Katie (in blue) taking a tackle at the 2004 NIT, when KM earned a 2nd place finish.
Congratulations to Katie! Wisconsin will be rooting for you.
Tuesday, October 30, 2007
The All Tournament Team
Kristy Fons, 12, Oak Creek
Monday, October 29, 2007
Good press, results, and some final thoughts
And now the final score reports and rankings for the Fall 2007 season:
7th Place Oak Creek 20 – Northshore Shore 10
5th Place Brookfield 40 – Kettle Moraine 10
3rd Place Catholic Memorial 22 - Muskego 15
State Champ DSHA 27 - Vernon 0
A special thanks to all the volunteers who put the state tournament together, especially Noe for taking on the thankless job of tournament coordinator and Wally, for his tireless efforts to get out the word to the press.
Hopefully, we'll be posting the names of the all state tournament team on this blog in a few days.
Wednesday, October 24, 2007
Coaching Changes/Rugby Alumnae
I know the league is glad to see that some of its first players are coming back to help-out and provide opportunities for other players. Fortunately, Katie Ehr won't be leaving the rugby scene for long as, rumor has it, she is getting her credentials as a sir and will be helping out with a whistle come spring. Good luck (and thank you) to both Katie and Kathrine as they take on new roles in the Girls Rugby community.
I think that other alumnae from other clubs are also in the mix for sir certification and coaching positions. We'll try to update when we learn of alumnae from other teams who are coming back to contribute.
Tuesday, October 23, 2007
Semin-Final Results
This means that Vernon will compete with DSHA for top honors on Sunday and Muskego will take-on Catholic Memorial for the 3rd place spot.
Good luck to all the teams as the finish up a very exciting season.
Monday, October 22, 2007
Play-off weekend
With the results still out on the two semi-final matches (DS v. Muskego and Vernon v. Catholic Memorial) which will determine who will play in the Finals and the 3rd place matches, here is the schedule for the play-off weekend.
7th Place Match 10:30am Oak Creek v. Northshore
5th Place Match 12pm Kettle Moraine v. Brookfield
3rd Place Match 1:30pm TBD
State Championship 3:00pm TBD
The State Tournament will feature the top eight high school girls rugby teams in the state, competing for their final ranking.
Milwaukee’s D.S.H.A. is a four-time National Champion and favored in the tournament.
The Town of Vernon is also a perennial powerhouse, finishing third in the country last season and first in their conference this season.
In the past year, Catholic Memorial H.S. and Oak Creek have added teams to one of the strongest conferences in the country
Friday, October 19, 2007
Rugby World Culture
Positive Player conduct:Key aspects to look out for in rugby include:
Low-key
celebrations - no
robotic dancing or going to the crowd
Any back-chat to
the referee is
punished by moving the penalty forward 10 yards
Players
rarely fake injury
Gracious in defeat - handshakes, as in football, and
"tunnels" of applause
at pitch-side, followed by socialising.Positive Fan Conduct
When in the stadium, there's no segregation - rival supporters sit
side-by-side (unlike football (soccer). Fans are expected to respect the anthems
and allow players to prepare to kick penalties without being whistled.
Wednesday, October 17, 2007
Any Press is Good Press
I konw the post match is a lot of work for teams and players and sometimes it doesn't seem to fit in to the hectic lifestyles we all live. But it is very rewarding to see the teams play hard and then take the time to share and socialize with the opposition.
Monday, October 15, 2007
State Quarterfinals
Muskego over OC 20-0
Vernon over Northshore 15-0
CHM over Brookfield 27-10
The fourth quarter final (DS v. KM) will be played this afternoon.
SO... next weekend's games:
Vernon v. CMH (Semi-final 1) (Vernon is the home team)
Muskego v. (winner of DS v. KM) Semin final 2
Brookfield v. Northshore (Brookfield is the home team)
OC v. (loser of DS v. KM)
State Quarterfinals
Muskego over OC 20-0
Vernon over Northshore 15-0
CHM over Brookfield 27-10
The fourth quarter final (DS v. KM) will be played this afternoon.
SO... next weekend's games:
Vernon v. CMH (Semi-final 1) (Vernon is the home team)
Muskego v. (winner of DS v. KM) Semin final 2
Brookfield v. Northshore (Brookfield is the home team)
OC v. (loser of DS v. KM)
Monday, October 8, 2007
Week 5 Standings
CMH(4-1) v. KM (1-4) 46-5 (5pts for CMH)
NS (1-4) v. DSHA 0-88 (5 pts. for DSHA)
Pool B:
Oak Creek (1-4) v. FDL (forfiet-- 5 pts .for OC)
Brookfield (2-2-1) v. Vernon 20-36 (5 pts .for Vernon; 1pts. for Brookfield for 4 or more tries)
Non-Pool Play:
Muskego v. DS-B 15-5
FINAL STANDINGS:
Pool A: (1) DS (20pts) (2) CMH ( 14 pts.); (3) Muskego (10 pts.); (4) NS (6 pts.) (5) KM ( 0 pts).
Pool B: (1) Vernon (15pts.); (2)Oak Creek (9 pts.).(3) Brookfield (7 pts) (4) FDL (0 pts.).
These are the final standings going into the 8-team play-off format. KM has qualified as the #4 seed in Pool B.
This weekend's quarterfinal games are:
DS v. KM
Vernon v. NS
CMH v. the Bruisers
The OC v. Muskego
Friday, October 5, 2007
Week 4 Standings
Pool A:
CMH(3-1) v. NS (1-3) 54-0 (5pts. for CMH)
Muskego (2-2) v KM (1-3) (24-12) (5pts. for Muskego)
Pool B:
Oak Creek (1-3) v. Brookfield (2-1-1) 19-15 (4pts. for The OC and 1 pt. for Brookfield)
DS-B v. Oak Creek 15-5 (no points)
Non-Pool Play
DS-A [No pool play]
Vernon v. UWM [Score Not Reported]
[SCORES NOT REPORTED]
Pool A: (1) DS (15pts) (2) Muskego (10 pts.); (3) CMH ( 9 pts.); (3) NS (6 pts.) (4) (5) KM ( 0 pts).
Pool B: (1) Vernon (10pts.); (2) Brookfield (6 pts), (3) Oak Creek (4 pts.). (4) FDL (0 pts.);
Thursday, September 27, 2007
Coach Needed
it would be a good idea to give it the widest circulation possible:
I am the manager for the North Shore Highlanders girls rugby team in Mequon. I am in urgent need of a coach. We have a pretty talented team, with a lot of underclassmen for players. This means that next year we can have a powerhouse of
a team. Only problem is I an in need of coaching. Our coach right now can't continue, new job responsibilities make it impossible for her to coach.We currently have 17-20 players on the team roster. We are a combination of
players from Mequon, Cedarburg, Whitefish Bay. We practice Monday, Tuesday and Thursdays at Kletche Park in Glendale. We only have two games left in our season, then we start our playoffs. The playoff run through the month of October, with the Final on October 28th.For the past two years we have travelled to Fullerton California in March to participate in an international tournament (they have teams from Canada). Last
year we took home the tournament trophy. I have been with this team for 6 years. I do all the planning, paying, and purchasing, etc etc. I really don't want to see this team fall apart, but without coaching there isn't anything I can do.Please let me know if you are interested in helping with the team. You can call me at home after 7:00 pm - #262-242-5120.
Thank you
Paula Luft
NorthShore Highlanders -
Manager
The Northshore Highlanders are one of our oldest clubs with a long and storied past. Aside from the accomplishments listed above, they placed 3rd at Nationals in a year when DSHA finished 5th. Let's not let that club go without a coach. Please pass this along to anyone who might be interested
Wednesday, September 26, 2007
Week 3 Standings
Week 3 Results:
Conference A:
CMH (2-1) v. Muskego (1-2) 10-5 (4pts. for CMH; 1 pt. for Muskego)
DS-A v. KM 79-0 (5pts. for conference standings)
Conference B:
FDL (0-3) v. Vernon (3-0) (0-86) (forfeit -- 5pts )
Oak Creek v. DS-B [Rescheduled to 10/4] (0 points for conference play)
Non-Conference
Brookfield (2-0-1) v. Northshore (1-2) 42-0 (0pts for standings)
STANDINGS:
Conference A: (1) DS (15pts) (2) NS (6 pts.) (3) Muskego (5 pts.); (4) CMH ( 4pts.) (5) KM ( 0 pts).
Conference B: (1) Vernon (10pts.); (2) Brookfield (5pts), (3) FDL (0 pts.); Oak Creek (0 pts.).
Monday, September 17, 2007
Week 2 Results
DSHA-A (2-0) v. CMH 35-5 (1-1) (5 pts for pool standings)
NS (1-1) v. Musk (1-1) 5-7 (4 pts. for Musk./1pt. for NS) for losing by less than 7 pts.).
Pool B:
DS-B (1-0-1) v. Brookfield (1-0-1) 10-10 (0 pts. for pool standings--per the rules)
Vernon (2-0) v. Oak Creek 29-0 (0-2) (5 tries scored) (5pts. for pool standings)
Non-Conference Matches:
FDL v. KM -----[0 pts for conference standings -- NOT REPORTED]
Current Standings:
Conference A: (1) DS (10pts) (2) NS (6 pts.) (3) Muskego (4 pts.); (4) CMH (0pts.) KM (0pts).
Conference B: (1) Brookfield (5pts), Vernon (5pts.); (2) FDL (0 pts.); Oak Creek (0 pts.).
Wednesday, September 12, 2007
Opening Weekend...
So, after week one of pool play the results are as follows:
Pool A:
DSHA-A (1-0) vs. Muskego 59-0 (0-1) (5pts for pool standings)
KM (0-1) v. Northshore (1-0) 14-32 (5pts for pool standings)
Pool B:
DS-B (0-1) v. Vernon 5-25 (1-0) (0 pts. for conference standings--per the rules)
FDL (0-1) v. Brookfield 10-53 (1-0) (5pts. for conference standings for technical forfeit)
Non-Conference Matches:
CMH (1-0) v. Oak Creek 33-0 (0-1) (0 pts for conference standings)
Current Standings:
Conference A: DS and NS are tied for 1st(5pts. each) with a 3 way tie for second (CMH, Musk. and KM).
Conference B: Brookfield is #1 in it's conference -- since no one else has played a conference match with a 4-way tie for 2nd place
Posted by Dan at 8:24 AM 0 comments
Labels: match reports
Friday, July 20, 2007
From other blogs...
Also, the Women's Rugby Review noted that USA Rugby has announced that it will sponsor, for the first time, a high school girls rugby championship, which is scheduled to be held on May 24-26, 2008.
Friday, June 15, 2007
More on the wee ones...
It has been great to see the rugby community pull together to offer this program to area youth. While some of the participants are children of rugby players, a majority of kids and their families are being exposed to rugby for the first time and having a very positive experience.
Tuesday, June 5, 2007
New Girls Play-Off Format..
Brookfield Bruiser's site posted a handy summary of the new play-off system on their website. Right below the Bruiser's schedule, the new pools are listed and if you click on the link to State Playoff Schedule, it will take you to the brackets for the last three weeks of the season.
Monday, June 4, 2007
Picture of the Week
A Fond du Lac (FDL) defender takes down a Brookfield ball carrier during Brookfield's 23-12 victory over FDL on June 2, 2007. I think this was the actual last game of the Spring 2007 season. FDL played a strong game, keeping Brookfield on the defensive for much of the fist half. However, Brookfield triumphed with speed out-wide and relentless goal-line defense. It is going to be an interesting fall with so many teams beginning to hit their stride.
Thursday, May 31, 2007
Youth Rugby Update
In the City of Waukesha, the particulars are as follows:
DATES: Saturday Mornings, from June 9 through June 30;
TIME: 9:00 a.m. to 10:00 a.m. (the hour goes quickly)
LOCATION: Mindiola Park (off of Sunset Dr. in Waukesha)
The program has 12 participants registered, but we are hoping for a bump in the final week of a few more kids. Their website is www.ci.waukehsa.wi.us. and I believe they are still accepting registrations.
The City of Oconomowoc is also running a four week program, running saturday mornings, starting on June 2, 2009. Information is available on thier website, www.oconomowocusa.com.
The West Bend Boys and Girls Club will be running a tag rugby program for elementary school aged children. They will be holding a high interest day on June 23, 2007, starting at 2:00 p.m.
Fond du Lac Rugby Club, in conjunction with the Fond du Lac park and recreation department is holding tag rugby programs, starting July 30 for children in grades 4-8. More information is available at www.fdlrugby.com..
All of these programs are co-ed and are a great introduction to rugby for players (and parent) with no experience or knoweldge about rugby.
If anyone knows about other programs, plesae leave a comment and spread the word.
Friday, May 25, 2007
The last games of Spring..
On Wenesday, May 23, Brookfield defeated Muskego 20-0 and Muskego-B downed CMH-B (score unreported).
I think next week will wrap-up everyone's Spring season. KM is hosting an alumnae game June 6, 2007 at 5:00. KM's alumnae game is a real tribute to the success of that program. Last year, the Alumnae showed up in force and KM played a full 15-a-side game. While the alumnae dominated play the first half using the wisdom of experience, age caught up with the alumnae in the second half. Good luck KM alum!
Also up-coming is Brookfield's and Fond du Lac's final game. They meet on June 2, 2007 at Minooka Park at 1:00 p.m.
I am pretty sure that these games are the wrap-up for the Spring Season for anyone that wants to get out and see one final game before the summer.
Thursday, May 24, 2007
Youth (6-8 year old) Rugby begins...
Oconomowoc and Waukesha Park and recreation departments are both sponsoring co-ed tag rugby programs this June. Hopefully these programs will grow and expand in the fall as well, depending upon support and interest.
Announcing our newest arrival ....
Northshore is continuing with a new coaching staff, Katie Ehr and Pam Waters. Katie and Pam formerly coached the Whitefish Bay RFC which merged with Northshore in the Spring of 2007. Katie and Pam are alumnae of the DSHA RFC. As the Girls Rugby league grows and ages, we are looking forward to more alumnae, from all our teams, returning to coach, referee and help-out.
As always, girls interested about joining (or starting) a team can follow the links on the side of this page to their local club and contact the coach. All teams (except DSHA and Catholic Memorial) accept high school age players from their local community or neighboring communities.
Tuesday, May 22, 2007
If you missed the NIT final...
If you didn't know Time Warner has been broadcasting some of the games for the West Side Harlequins on this station as well. This was a really nice feature. Unfortunately, Time Warner does not carry Setanta Sports, so I'm going to have to drop cable before the World Cup starts this Fall. But, in the meantime, its nice to see the local teams get air time.
Monday, May 21, 2007
Picture of the Week
And the winners are...
Brookfield placed 4th after a difficult loss to City Honors/Genesse (NY) 25-12 in the 3rd place math of the Plate division. The Plate division ended with an all Oregon final as West Linn downed Canby 24-10.
I didn't get to see as many matches as I would have liked, but the matches I saw were exciting. The final round of the Cup division was a particularly close game. The DSHA/Kent game saw some great pressure and defense by both teams. After trading penalty kicks early in the first half, with the score 3-3, the match was at issue for sixty-minutes. Both teams had some tough goal line stands. In the end, DSHA punched through two unconverted tries to win the day, but not without a fight.
Now it's time for all the other teams in Wisconsin to start preparing for the Fall and a chance to knock DSHA out of the running before the next National Tournament.
Friday, May 18, 2007
Results from Spring of 2007...so far
But, given those limitations, here is a summary of the spring season to date (winning team in bold)
Pre-Season
Northshore Trip to Littleton International Tournament.
Week 1
DSHA v. Northshore 20-10
Verson v. DSHA-B (score not reported)
Week 2
DSHA v. Brookfield 63-0
DSHA-B v. Brookfield-B 24-0
Wayzata (MN) v. CMH 17-14
East Metro v. CMH B 24-0
Week 3
Vernon v. KM 32-5
Vernon-B v. Brookfield 5-12
Northshore v. Muskego 15-5
Week 4
Vernon v. Fond du Lac 25-12
DSHA v. Fond du Lac 39-0
CMH v. St. Charles (IL) 51-0
CMH-B v. St. Charles (IL) 10-12
Northshore v. KM 19-0
Northshore v. Brookfield 0-0
KM v. Brookfield 5-12
Week 5
Muskego v. Vernon 5-39
Brookfield v. CMH 19-14
Brookfield-B v. CMH-B 5-47
Northshore v. Vernon 0-10
CMH v. Muskego 45-5
Week 6
Midwest Girls Rugby Chapionship.
Week 7
Vernon v. Brookfield 59-5
KM v. CMH 32-21
Week 8
National Invitational Tournament.
Those are the scores that I have for matches played up until May 18 for the Spring 2007 season... If I missed reported (or missed) any scores, let me know. I will admit that because of the shifting dates for games this season the week by week break-down is really just to make the list more reader-friendly.
Thursday, May 17, 2007
The details for the Girls Rugby NIT...
While I will certainly be rooting for our Wisconsin teams, I am excited to see some of the perennial power-houses compete (like Kent and Summit) who have been competing in the NIT for year. In addition, there are some new teams from states that, to my knowledge, haven't attended the NIT in the past (like the Lady Marauders from Maryland and Oconee from Georgia). Check out the NIT website for full details about the teams coming to compete.
Good luck to all the teams! I'm looking forward to watching some competitive rugby this weekend.
Tuesday, May 15, 2007
Press for Nationals and DSHA
This should be a great opportunity for anyone in Wisconsin who is interested in seeing high school girls rugby at its finest.
Monday, May 14, 2007
Picture of the Week
Midwest Girls Rugby Chapionships
While I owe a whole entry to that event because it was so exciting, the big news is the results from the Midwest Girls Rugby Chapionship. Vernon and DSHA represented Wisconsin in the Tournament and both teams progressed through the brackets undefeated. In the final round, DSHA defeated Vernon 36-0 in the all Wisconsin finals. Congratulations to our Wisconsin teams on another outstanding Midwest Tournament.
We are all looking forward to a chance to cheer on our Wisconssin clubs in the National Tournament on May 19-20th here in Franklin, WI.
Thursday, April 19, 2007
Deciding Wisconsin's #3 Seed
The application of the experiminatal point system would have ranked Northrhore 3rd, Brookfield 4th, and KM 5th, but the rule was not in place at the start of the season. The pont system awards a team 4 ponits for a win; 2 points for a tie, and 1 bonus point for scoring 4 or more trys in a match; and 1 bonus point for losing by less than 7 points.
In the spirit of sportsmanship and competition, the coaches agreed to a one day, round-robin tournament this spring to see who will be Wisconsin's #3 seed. The games will be held at Nagawaukee Park, April 22, starting at 11:00 a.m. The winning team will emerge with bragging rights and the will represent Wisconsin in the open division of the Midwest tournament.
It is going to be an exciting day of rugby at Nagawaukee.
Thursday, April 12, 2007
Even more on varsity girls rugby...
One commentator had some positive things to say which I think are worth repeating:
There are no negatives to interscholastic athletics...none.
Providing opportunities for student-athlete enrichment never has a down side.
Parents, BOE, AD's, coaches, teachers, community leaders will find a way if they have the students best interest as their focus
I agree with these points, and would add that if all individuals involved came to the table around a particular sport with these beliefs, there would be a lot of positive results. The attitude of the players, rugby coaches, parents, as well as school leaders and coaches of existing sports, is essential to moving forward (as the commentator appropriately coined it).
I have one more thought (for now), based on a conversation I had recently with a school administrator. Club sports should not come to the table demanding varsity status and demanding resources. This only creates conflict or potential conflict between the school community and the club. Rather, club sports, such as rugby, should come to the table and offer something of value to the school community, i.e. a new opportunity for student involvement and a set of supportive volunteers.
At this early stage in the game, having a positive school-club relationship (which allows teams to form an identity around the school and increases recruiting/publicity opportunities) far outweighs any short term gain from having varsity status. Varsity status will come over time as a result of overall growth in the sport, and not through pressure by individual clubs on individual school athletic programs.
I would note that other models, i.e. the community based model, have been very successful. Vernon has built its program through its park and recreation department. The focus on varsity/school based rugby should not overshadow the fact that local park and recreation departments have been and continue to be a real resource for the girls rugby clubs here in Wisconsin.
Tuesday, April 10, 2007
Vernon.... still a strong #2
Is it possible that Wisconsin will repeat last year's performance where Wisconsin teams captuered the #1 (DSHA) and #2 (Vernon Park) spots in the Midwest Tournament?
Wisconsin should be proud of its repeated success at the Midwest Tournament and the ability of both its #1 and #2 seed to advance in the tournement brackets.
Monday, April 9, 2007
More on Varsity Girls Rugby
First, the commenter took the post as a slam on USA Rugby. However, the post actually cretids USA Rugby with initiating a serious conversation about how to bring about varsity rugby.
Second, my comments were not oppossed to varsity status, rather a caution that varsity status is not an automatic solution to rugby's problem. In fact, the commenter and I seem to agree that there would be benefits to varsity status, i.e. legitimacy within the school, access to another, well organized sports structure and more exposure. (In fact, the orignal post pointed out that a two tier club/varisty stem "may not be a bad result if it means more exposure to rugby for everyone.").
Third, I think the original post indicates, and I would stil maintain, that capacity is a real issue for rugby community at this stage of the game. Creating "varsity" programs assumes that we can find enough coaches, referees, (and not to mention players) to have that happen. These resources need to be developed locally. The question is not "how do we get varsity status?" but "how do we build capacity?"
Ultimately, if rugby achieves varsity status it will be because of (and not in spite of) the success of the current club teams. Only when our club teams are strong and regularly drawing players, will there be enough evidence to encourage school districts to sponsor varsity programs. No school or athlectic association is going to "give" varsity status to rugby, varsity status must be earned by building a strong base.
Finally, I want to comment on the rugby volunteer/ownership comment. For rugby to grow, each participant (parent, player, coaches, etc..) must "own" rugby. Without investment in the process, rugby won't grow. However, I would agree with the commenter that this sense of "ownership" is dangerous if it leads to the exclusion of "non-rugby" people --- a term I dislike. Rugby needs to do a better job at brining people in and showing them that this is a legitimate, fun, and exciting sport for all involved.
Monday, April 2, 2007
A new up and coming powerhouse...
One score from this weekend made me stand up and take note.... Northsore v. Muskego (15-5).
Northsore placed 3rd in the fall and Muskego 6th. This past fall, Northshore downed Muskego 38-0. But rumor has it that Muskego has spent the winter recruiting and building this still young team which now fields 2 full sides. And it certainly seems the efforts have paid-off. Moreover, with Northore's recent success on tour in California, there is no doubt that Northshore put up a fight this past weekend. By narrowing the point difference to 10 points, Muskego is clearly throwing its hat in the ring to be in the top half of the conference this fall.
Muskego may just be the up-and-coming team for the fall conference. As always, the questions for the fall...who is losing seniors and how many?
Friday, March 30, 2007
Picture of the week
Thursday, March 29, 2007
Plugging holes with our thumbs....
In the meantime, even if one crisis is averted, putting our collective thumbs in the wall does little to stem the rising tides of problems behind the levy.
Here is Wisconsin, I think we've done pretty well at the U19 level in forming new teams and leagues. The boys have 2 separate conferences, and the girls have a number of very strong clubs with at least 2 sides. But, we cannot rest on our successes. Wisconsin has a grass-roots tradition to brag about. But, as we grow our U19 program, we increasingly stress the resources (fields, referees, coaches) to the limit.
Here is my off-the-cuff proposal. Let's create a marketing committee within the Union which pulls together members from all the various interest groups (referees, coaches, men's, women's, collegiate, boys, girls and youth programs). The purpose of this committee will be to market the sport of rugby in Wisconsin, regardless of level. My theory is that a broad based marketing campaign would help rugby at all levels. We in the rugby community already believe this is a great sport. Let's create the buzz in the rest of the community, so that non-rugby players begin to ask questions: Where can I watch a game? How do I become a sir? Where can I play rugby?
All our clubs can benefit from unified marketing, which actively includes all levels of rugby, and brands rugby as sport for the whole community.
Wednesday, March 28, 2007
Picture of the Week
For more information on the U19 tour, check out the U19 girls rugby blog (link on side of page) or the USA Rugby home page.
Tuesday, March 27, 2007
Varsity Status for Girls Rugby
The WIAA, Wisconsin's high school athletics governing body, has its own set of regulations governing high school sports. This may lead to inconsistencies between the current practice here in Wisconsin (i.e. a Fall season for rankings within the state and a Spring season for touring and participation in Mid-west/National tournaments). This type of system could be eliminated by WIAA rules which may prohibit out-of-season play.
In my mind, here are advantages to seeking WIAA membership:
- Part of a pre-existing structure to help organize/standardized administration;
- Legitimacy within schools to facilitate recruiting players;
- Access to school resources and funding.
However, there are some serious draw backs:
- Inability of high school teams to compete in territorial and national competitions;
- WIAA discourages (but does allow) multi-school teams for areas where no team is available;
- The team becomes linked to school district budgetary needs (e.g., the Waukesha School District is thinking about eliminating ALL extra-curricular activities and sports ).
USA rugby appears to think that high school varsity status is a natural result of or beneficial to its goal of NCAA status for collegiate women. However, looking at the soccer model suggests that varsity status is not necessary as a feeder system for collegiate programs. The best recruits for soccer (at least in this area) come not from high school varsity squads, but from community based select side teams. Varsity soccer is usually a step down from the club soccer.
By pushing an agenda of varsity rugby for high school girls, we are ultimately pushing towards a two tier system (club rugby and varsity rugby) similar to soccer. This may not be a bad result if it means more exposure to rugby for everyone. However, this presupposes that we in the rugby community have the capacity to support this level of involvement in terms of qualified referees and coaches. On the other hand, if the push for varsity status back-fires, varsity girls rugby within a WIAA structure could eliminate the more flexible club rugby. This would be a real loss to the club rugby programs because national tournaments and touring opportunities have been a real recruiting tool for local teams. Perhaps the better question is not how do we push for varsity status, but how do we collectively build support to grow the current club system? What do we need to grow high school rugby?
I would suggest that the answers will vary from state to state. Now that USARFU has broached this important subject, it is up to local clubs to carry on the dialouge and find solutions that work for local communities.
Friday, March 23, 2007
Wisconsin participation in USA U19 Tour
Congratulations to our local players!
Wednesday, March 21, 2007
Congratulations Northshore!
It was an awesome weekend!!!! Yes, we won the tournament!!!
Our touring group was 20 girls but the day before we left 4 had to pull out, because they came down with that ugly flue that was going around, so we traveled light with only 16 girls.
In the very first game my wing broke her arm so we were down to 15 for the rest of the tournament. Before each game the referee would stop by and ask that the subs check in through the table at the side of the field before they would be aloud on the field. My response to this was: "There is no need for that Sir, what you have on the field is what you have". They usually thought I was joking.Saturday:
Game 1: Northshore Highlanders vs. Coburg East Comets from Ontario Canada 19
- 5 (We scored 3 tries)Game 2: Northshore Highlanders vs. Cantwell from California 47 - 3 (We scored 7
tries)
Sunday:Semi-Final: Northshore Highlanders vs. Fullerton Lady Lions from California (Hosting Team) 5 - 0
Final: Northshore Highlanders vs. Surrey Eagles from British Columbia 5 - 0
The girls wanted it really badly and that made the difference. Of the 15 we came home with one broken nose, one with a double hairline fracture in her foot and one with a dislocated finger, which might be broken, she was going in for x-rays today. The rest was all black and blue from the bruises and there was some really nice grass burns, but winning made up for it.
Friday, March 16, 2007
Picture of the week...
Building Teams...
Based on conversations I have had with coaches, observations of various team structures, and personal experience, I think the number 1 obstacle to maintaining a U19 girls team is recruitment. It appears that once a player has a game or two under their belt, the majority of players (and their parents) really come to love the sport. So, what are the recruitment obstacles? Why do some teams succeed in finding numbers and others do not?
Thursday, March 15, 2007
Coaching Girls...
Good luck to Northshore...
Wednesday, March 14, 2007
Youth Rugby Opportunities
I just wanted to put out a quick post of upcoming and planned youth programs in Wisconsin (by which I mean non-contact programs for U6-U14 aged players):
- May 9, 2007: City of Waukesha, Rugby High Interest Day for grades 1-4. (more information forthcoming)
- June 5-21, 2007: Catholic Memorial High School, Rugby Camp for children entering grades 6-8. Information available at the Catholic Memorial Webiste (follow the link on side of this page and clik on summer camp information);
- Saturdays in June, 2007: City of Waukesha, Rugby Camp for children in grades 1-4. (More information forthcoming).
- Program details for the 2007-2008 tag rugby league for players grades 1-4 and a "Little Rugby Academy" for players in grades K4 and K5 can be found at wisconsinruggers.com. Registration Fall 2007 K-4 programs can be picked up at the Town of Brookfield (http://www.townofbrookfield.com/) and on line at Wisconsinruggers.com.
If you know anyone who might be interested in either participating or creating a youth rugby program in Wisconsin, please pass along this information.
Monday, March 12, 2007
Saturday's A Rugby Day: "Waste your money and you're only out of money, but waste your time and you've lost a part of your life."
If you look at the tax returns of local soccer associations, these organizations are bringing in $150 to $500K. These associations have the resources to buy fields, pay coaches, and develop players from the youngest levels. Think what a club could do if it had these kinds of resources!
Not to mention, if we can have semi-professional teir-II arena footbal or women's footbal, don't you think the public would come watch some premier rugby? Perhaps we need to bring in general managers and community organizers for our local rugby clubs.
Not too far away...
Friday, March 9, 2007
Picture of the Week...
Once the season begins, you can email your pictures from your favorite Wisconsin U19 team and we will post the "winning" picture on the site.
The U19 Girls Season Opening Day
Keep posted as we track down the latest match reports.